The E46 is a classic now – and as with any classic, what matters when buying is not so much the year as how that particular car has been looked after over the years. This generation has a few weak points that have been well known for a long time, yet still regularly catch buyers out, because they do not always show themselves on a short test drive.
Plastic cooling system – a weak point common to the whole generation
What to look out for
- Coolant expansion tank – the plastic becomes brittle over time and cracks, usually without warning.
- Thermostat housing – another plastic part prone to cracking under heat cycles.
- Water pump – on many cars it has a plastic impeller, which eventually crumbles and stops cooling the engine effectively.
- Replacement history of these parts – if the cooling system has already been comprehensively replaced with new parts, that is a big plus and worth asking about directly.
VANOS – valve timing adjustment on the 6-cylinder engines (M52TU, M54)
What to look out for
- Characteristic rattling at start-up – a typical symptom of worn O-rings in the VANOS system.
- Loss of power in the mid rev range – another sign of problems with the valve timing adjustment.
- VANOS service history – replacing the seals alone is a relatively inexpensive repair, but if neglected it can lead to wear of the mechanism.
M43 – an older, simpler four-cylinder engine
What to look out for
- The same plastic cooling system as on the 6-cylinder engines – the problem affects the whole E46 generation, whichever engine it has.
- Simpler design without VANOS – less electronics, but it is still worth checking the basic engine operating parameters and the timing history (a belt rather than a chain on this version).
Rear subframe – a structural matter, not an engine one
On the E46, especially the coupe and convertible versions and cars driven in a sportier manner, the mounting points of the rear subframe to the body can weaken over time. BMW has made official reinforcement kits available for this problem – it is worth checking whether the car already has them, especially on cars with a clearly sporty history of use.
None of these points on its own rules out the E46 as a sensible purchase – they are simply well-known places that have to be verified on a car of this age. Pre-purchase diagnostics shows whether the seller has already dealt with them or is leaving them to the next owner.
Checklist before viewing an E46
- Boot floor and rear subframe mounts. Cracks in the sheet metal here are the most serious structural defect of the model.
- Corrosion. Rear wheel arch edges, sills and lower door edges.
- Cooling system. The age of the expansion tank, radiator and water pump. No replacement documents means an expense in the near future.
- Window regulators. Check all of them.
- Engine running when cold. Hunting revs usually point to intake leaks or the crankcase ventilation.
What diagnostics will show on such an old car
Fuel trims immediately reveal intake leaks, and the VANOS, lambda sensor and engine temperature parameters say more than a test drive. We also read the mileage stored in the instrument cluster and in the light module, because discrepancies between them give away a wound-back odometer. We describe the symptoms of typical faults in our articles on VANOS and the DISA valve.
Frequently asked questions
Because BMW used plastic parts in it – the expansion tank, the thermostat housing and, on many cars, the water pump impeller too – which become brittle with age and heat cycles and crack, usually without any prior warning.
Not every one, but it is one of the points worth checking – especially on coupes, convertibles and cars driven in a sportier manner. BMW has made official reinforcement kits available for this problem.
Not always – in many cases replacing just the O-ring seals is enough, which is a relatively cheap repair. The problem only becomes expensive once neglect leads to wear of the mechanism itself.
Got a particular E46 in mind?
We will check the cooling system, VANOS and the subframe mounts before you pay.
Book pre-purchase diagnostics