Many people consider the E39 one of the best-engineered generations of the 5 Series ever – and rightly so, but that does not mean it has no typical weak points. The difference is that at this age it is no longer the model that matters, but whether someone along the way has dealt with these specific, well-known points.
Plastic cooling system – the same problem as on the E46
What to look out for
- Expansion tank and thermostat housing – plastic parts that tend to crack with age, whatever the engine version.
- Water pump – on the inline engines of this generation the impeller often loses efficiency.
- Replacement history – if the cooling system has already been comprehensively refreshed, that is a very good sign.
VANOS on the 6-cylinder engines (M52TU, M54)
What to look out for
- Rattling at start-up – a typical symptom of worn O-rings in the VANOS system.
- Smoothness in the mid rev range – a loss of performance here is another sign of problems with the valve timing adjustment.
M62 V8 – an engine with its own distinct weak point
What to look out for
- Timing chain guides – they wear with age and can cause a characteristic rattle, and in extreme cases lead to a more serious engine failure.
- History of guide replacement – if it has already been done, it is worth confirming with an invoice.
- Valve stem seals – a typical cause of rising oil consumption as mileage builds up.
EHC suspension – self-levelling rear axle
On versions with self-levelling rear suspension (EHC), especially common on the estate (Touring), it is worth checking the hydraulic pump and the actuators. Suspension that does not return to the correct height after loading is a sign of an approaching, sometimes expensive repair.
None of these points on its own rules out the E39 as a purchase – quite the opposite, this car can run for a very long time with a little care. Pre-purchase diagnostics shows how much of that care a particular car has already had.
Checklist before viewing an E39
- Corrosion. Sills, wheel arch edges, lower door edges and the area around the boot lid.
- Instrument cluster. Burnt-out display pixels are a common complaint on this model.
- ABS and DSC warning lights. Control module damage is typical for this generation.
- Front suspension. Steering wheel vibration under braking usually points to worn wishbone bushes.
- Engine temperature. The gauge should sit steady in the middle of the scale and the heating should work evenly.
What diagnostics will show on such an old car
Despite its age the E39 has a dozen or so control units that store faults and parameters. We read fuel trims, VANOS operation, temperatures and the condition of the lambda sensors. This data lets us tell a well-kept car from one that only looks good. We describe how to diagnose these units in our article on classic M-series engines, and everyday care in the maintenance recommendations.
Frequently asked questions
Yes – the M62 has its own weak point in the form of wearing timing chain guides, which the smaller inline engines of this generation do not have. Otherwise it shares the typical problems of the plastic cooling system with them.
The repair can be expensive if it concerns the hydraulic pump or the actuators – so it is worth checking that the self-levelling works before you buy, rather than hoping you happen to have found a good one.
Mileage on its own says less than the service history. A well-kept car with an already replaced cooling system and a healthy VANOS can be a better buy than a seemingly "fresh" car with no history at all.
Got a particular E39 in mind?
We will check the cooling system, VANOS and – if it is a V8 – the chain guides, before you pay.
Book pre-purchase diagnostics